'Stop the fighting'; 'Yes, sir, will do' – unbelievable
Deutsche Presse-Agentur wired another story about an hour after the one I quoted in the post before this. It which includes the following:
Borg broke ranks on another issue, arguing that the priority should not be forcing Gaddafi out, but to get an end to the violence.
‘Stop the fighting and then we shall see what happens,’ Borg said, adding that if a UN-mandated ceasefire was not respected, ‘further action’ from the UN would follow, on top of sanctions already enforced against Gaddafi’s clique.
‘An immediate ceasefire is today the priority,’ Italy’s Foreign Minister Franco Frattini said.
Diplomatic sources said that Greece and Cyprus also backed the idea, but there was some ambiguity on whether other countries agreed with Malta that Gaddafi’s ouster was not a precondition.
—–
Perhaps Tonio Borg would now like to explain to us whether his idea of a ceasefire covers torture, arbitrary imprisonment and kidnapping.
Doctors Without Borders/Medecins Sans Frontieres today issued a press statement. Our foreign minister, who is so very keen on protecting foetuses, might care to explain what Malta’s view is on this. I can hear the response already: “The violence must stop.”
Libya: Concern For Plight of Wounded Cut Off From Aid
MSF Calls For Unhindered Access to Medical Care
GENEVA/NEW YORK, MARCH 12, 2011 – As conflict intensifies in Libya, the international medical humanitarian organisation Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) is extremely concerned for wounded people caught in violent clashes, and calls for their urgent, unhindered access to medical assistance, irrespective of any political considerations.
For the past three weeks MSF teams based on the Tunisian border and in the eastern city of Benghazi have been providing medical supplies to health facilities in Libya, and have actively attempted to access areas in the west of the country, where fighting is taking place.
In several conflict zonesa, such as Zawiyah and Misrata, large numbers of people are cut off from any external assistance, amidst reports of critical medical needs and shortages of medicines and other medical materials.
“We are deeply concerned with the denial of access to medical care and the plight of patients in public health facilities within government-controlled areas,” said Bruno Jochum, MSF director of operations.
As an emergency medical humanitarian organization, MSF reaffirms the importance of responding effectively to people’s urgent medical needs, regardless of their affiliations.
“Our main challenge today is to gain immediate access to the people affected by violence inside Libya,” said Jochum. “Despite ongoing intense fighting, our medical teams, which have been deliberately blocked at the Tunisian border town of Ras Ajdir for weeks now, have not seen any injured patients authorized to cross into Tunisia. It is essential that people have the possibility to flee combat zones to find refuge in safe areas inside Libya or abroad.”
Adherence to medical ethics and international humanitarian law by all belligerents—including respect for medical facilities, vehicles and personnel—is the only way patients will receive the urgent medical care they need.
MSF continues to assist the civilian population through the delivery of medical supplies in Libya. Since the first MSF team was able to enter eastern Libya on February 24, 22 tons of medical supplies have been distributed to areas where the most acute needs have been identified. Eleven more tons of medical materials are ready to be delivered where ongoing fighting has created supply shortages.
10 Comments Comment
Leave a Comment


How would a ceasefire be enforced?
Perhaps it’s time to start calling for the second resignation: Tonio Borg’s.
Done: http://baxxterswar.wordpress.com/2011/03/13/should-maltese-foreign-minister-tonio-borg-resign/
The case against a no-fly zone:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12708727
Arab League backs Libya no-fly zone:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12723554
At this point, it would be better if our politicians hid behind the convenient “neutrality” and refrained from saying anything. It would be less embarrassing for all of us.
Have any of our gormless and vacillating politicians read this?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12707359
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12695134
This is the sort of guy they are appeasing.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12720402
Some more people who should be asked whether removing Gaddafi will bring about Tonio’s ceasefire.
If this is the government’s position, then it needs to establish contact with the rebels. You cannot call for a ceasefire while calling for the leader of the only side you have contact with to step down.
It is clear from the report quoted that Malta is not isolated on this issue.
Certainly the priority must be the saving of lives, the prevention of violence and the effective provision of humanitarian aid. People’s lives and their safety and health come before politics. If fighting continues, the humantiarian crisis will increase.
[Daphne – Malta IS isolated, David the Nitpicker. All 27 EU member states agreed on the resolution calling for Gaddafi to step down immediately, then Malta in the form of its foreign minister backed down himself instead. ]
A ceasefire must be followed, as I had suggested previously, by diplomatic efforts aiming at finding a solution to the Libyan crisis. If these fail, other modes of action must be considered to end the conflict. This is also the view of relief organizations. http://www.reliefweb.int/rw/rwb.nsf/db900sid/VVOS-8ETS6R?OpenDocument
There are many risks in a military option, which may not solve the current crisis http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12708727
A ceasefire would play right into the hands of Gaddafi, as the rebels would never agree to it (for good reasons).
If Gaddafi respects the ceasefire and the rebels don’t, then any military action by the international community following would have to be taken against them instead and any military response by Gaddafi would suddenly be justified.
A ceasefire is a cruel method of returning legitimacy to Gaddafi.
Guess this is too difficult to grasp for a simple foreign minister.